Mexico City legalizes abortion: Is it fleeting from the control of the Roman Catholic Church? - Instablogs
Mexico City legalizes abortion: Is it fleeting from the control of the Roman Catholic Church?
Pooja , Shimla: Apr 25 2007
Made Popular Apr 25 2007

Mexico City legalizes abortion: Is it fleeting from the control of the Roman Catholic Church?
Mexico City is in hay wire these days, why? Well the lawmakers have given a green signal to abortion. The proposal has immensely swayed the policies and health practices across Mexico and other parts of Roman Catholic Latin America.

The new legislation permits that the city hospitals would provide the procedure in the first trimester and does open the way for private abortion clinics. However, girls under 18 of age would have to get their parental consent for carrying out an abortion.

The procedure will be almost free for poor or the uninsured city residents, but is unlikely to attract patients from the United States, where later-term abortion is legal in many states. Under the Mexico City law, women having an abortion after 12 weeks face punishment of three to six months in jail. Those performing abortions after that period would face one to three years in jail.

The Roman Catholic Church has protested the measure and Mexico City Cardinal Norberto Rivera led a march through the capital last month in opposition. The Archdiocese asserted that it would ‘evaluate the moral consequences of the reforms’.

Cuba and Guyana are the only countries in Latin America and the Caribbean with legalized abortion for all women. Most others allow it only in cases of rape or when the woman’s life is at risk. Nicaragua, El Salvador and Chile forbid it completely.

However, statistics reveal that a majority of Mexico City residents support legalized abortions, at least in the first weeks of pregnancy.

Emotional confrontation

The proposal has created a kind of turmoil where Roman Catholic forms a bulk, for whom, abortion is a morally corrupt deed.

Opponents advocate that life begins at conception and say the law would violate the Mexican Constitution’s protection of individual rights. Supporters say the law would save the lives of thousands of women.

One aspect of abortion laws is particularly strange and distasteful — namely, the ‘except for rape and incest’ clause in some laws. Isn’t the foundation of anti-abortion law the belief that a fetus is a full-fledged human from the moment of conception? If so, how can abortion foes allow the ‘murder’ of an innocent child who just happened to be conceived through rape or incest? That’s not the child’s fault and certainly no justification for murdering it.

Of course, terminating the growth of an unformed fetus isn’t murder or even close. But the Church must insist that it is murder, because Christian dogma is based on the premise that a ’soul’ is injected into the human egg at the moment of conception.

Effect of the proposal

Mexico’s legalization of abortion would be entirely foreseeable that American women would travel south if their own government continues to tighten restrictions on the procedure.

However, one must not forget, women those who have access to safe contraception, reproductive health care and legal abortion, the actual abortion rates are much lower than in countries where women do not have such rights.

But one must not forget, living in a society where marital statuses socially matter for every birth and the crime against life that every abortion done makes, are extreme positions that need to be reconciled.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
0 Stars
Let’s leave religion aside. it’s not about religion. It’s about our society and about adults lacking responsibility.

The main problem with abortion, not mentioned in much of the talks is the lack of responsibility it creates in society.

No doubt we all know that there are always chances of a female getting pregnant when she gets engaged in a sexual behavior (Ideal sex practices) with a male no matter what sort of protection they use. However, it is strange to see when people act like it was some sort of miracle that it happened. This is a fact of life and so having an abortion to me is a lack of respect of being a responsible adult engaging in sexual relations.
0 Stars
I cannot understand why infant killing or abortion is legalized in the Mexico city because it is crime against humanity that should not be legalized and should be punished.

This makes me bit apprehensive that how the lawmakers can legalize the abortion because this is something equal to murdering an infant who haven’t committed any crime and why should he or she should suffer for the pleasure of responsible adults engaged in sexual relations or by committing sins time and again.

I am also not able to find the answer that are the lawmakers so obsessed with sex that they don’t want to make any compromises with the sexual pleasures or are they promoting the sins or pleasure of their adults one’s to let them enjoy their sexual pleasures without any protections.

I think this law should only be legalized in some exceptional cases when mother’s position is critical at the time of delivery or at time of rapes or for youngsters below 18.

This law should only be used to protect one’s life and only in some exceptional cases as discussed above and I think Mexican people are well grown that they will understand this easily if the lawmakers try once to make them understand.
1 Stars
Pawan
New Delhi, India
I disagree with the two friends. Abortion is a personal choice and should be treated like that.

Even Plato and ARistotle had been supporters of abortion under certain cicumstances. Instead of moving ahead we seem to be moving back.

And let us not get emotional over it. Showing the baby on the cross should not deviate us from the pros and cons.

What about people who have casual sex and dont want to have a baby . Does the society have to force them ? What about a married couple who despite using all precautions end up finding they may be parents once again ....does the society have to force it ....despite the circumstances......

The only care what i feel should be taken is to make sure that the life of the woman undergoing abortion should not be in threat if abortion is undertaken.

And dear friend...do not compare it what dear friend Manish has written ” this is something equal to murdering an infant who haven’t committed any crime and why should he or she should suffer for the pleasure of responsible adults engaged in sexual relations or by committing sins time and again.” ......if we go by this notion then each married couple may have to committed hundreds or perhaps thousand of murders as the even denying the sperm to fertilise is equivalent to denying someone to start a life.....

#postcomment
0 Stars
I agree with the the views pin pointed above...It is definately a personnel choice...

However, lawmakers should take care that the law should not be used for any evil propagandas any how.

Everyone needs to be responsible..
Add your Comment